Bukfan
"The law is wrong; I am right"
Some of the songs in the movie are apparently slower than they are on record and CD. Some guy mentioned it in the reviews on Amazon:
"
The reason the audio sounds slower in the film on many of the songs as compared to the LP/CD releases has nothing to do with the Beatles speeding up or slowing down the master tapes. They did not actively begin doing that in studio until later in their careers (around "Revolver" and especially with "Sgt. Pepper.").
Rather, all sequences shot in the television studio set were filmed at 25 frames per second, rather than the standard 24 frames per second. This is because the television monitors used on the set were PAL monitors, which natively display images at 25 fps. Had the sequences been filmed at 24 fps, the monitors in the background would have flickered, due to the film running at a different speed than the images they were projecting. Realizing this would be very, very distracting, Lester made the decision to shoot these sequences at a slightly faster speed, then slow them down by one fps for the final product.
Unfortunately, the recordings used for playbacks on the set were not adjusted accordingly. Thus, when the film was slowed down, the pitch of the audio was also lowered. This is especially obvious in the song "And I Love Her." McCartney's voice does NOT sound as deep as it is presented in the film, nor is his diction that slow and drawling. Compare that song to the LP and it becomes clear it is the same recording played at a slower speed. "Tell Me Why" also suffers, as the high-tempo recording on the LP becomes a moderate-time dragfest in the film.
The most obvious case, however, is "She Loves You," played as the final number in the television performance. The recording is clearly the 1963 single master. If you watch the chords Lennon and Harrison are playing as they sync to it, they are clearly playing in E minor/G major, as they did in the original recording. However, the pitch of the song is almost a semitone lower, again due to the sequence being filmed at 25 fps.
Songs that are NOT performed in the television studio set ("I Should Have Known Better," "Can't Buy Me Love," and "A Hard Day's Night") are played at their original pitch and match what is heard on the LP.
Now, I know for authenticity they should leave the audio alone and have the songs slower on the Blu-ray, but you would think in this day and age they could provide as an option at least for the songs to be artificially sped up to synchronize with the film, yet retain their original pitch. Since I, unfortunately, am cursed with perfect pitch, I find these parts of the film almost unwatchable, as I KNOW the songs should be played at higher pitch.
Hopefully, this provides some insight as to why many of the songs are at the wrong pitch."
- I wonder if anybody except audiophiles will notice it. I have an earlier DVD version of the movie and I never noticed it.
"
The reason the audio sounds slower in the film on many of the songs as compared to the LP/CD releases has nothing to do with the Beatles speeding up or slowing down the master tapes. They did not actively begin doing that in studio until later in their careers (around "Revolver" and especially with "Sgt. Pepper.").
Rather, all sequences shot in the television studio set were filmed at 25 frames per second, rather than the standard 24 frames per second. This is because the television monitors used on the set were PAL monitors, which natively display images at 25 fps. Had the sequences been filmed at 24 fps, the monitors in the background would have flickered, due to the film running at a different speed than the images they were projecting. Realizing this would be very, very distracting, Lester made the decision to shoot these sequences at a slightly faster speed, then slow them down by one fps for the final product.
Unfortunately, the recordings used for playbacks on the set were not adjusted accordingly. Thus, when the film was slowed down, the pitch of the audio was also lowered. This is especially obvious in the song "And I Love Her." McCartney's voice does NOT sound as deep as it is presented in the film, nor is his diction that slow and drawling. Compare that song to the LP and it becomes clear it is the same recording played at a slower speed. "Tell Me Why" also suffers, as the high-tempo recording on the LP becomes a moderate-time dragfest in the film.
The most obvious case, however, is "She Loves You," played as the final number in the television performance. The recording is clearly the 1963 single master. If you watch the chords Lennon and Harrison are playing as they sync to it, they are clearly playing in E minor/G major, as they did in the original recording. However, the pitch of the song is almost a semitone lower, again due to the sequence being filmed at 25 fps.
Songs that are NOT performed in the television studio set ("I Should Have Known Better," "Can't Buy Me Love," and "A Hard Day's Night") are played at their original pitch and match what is heard on the LP.
Now, I know for authenticity they should leave the audio alone and have the songs slower on the Blu-ray, but you would think in this day and age they could provide as an option at least for the songs to be artificially sped up to synchronize with the film, yet retain their original pitch. Since I, unfortunately, am cursed with perfect pitch, I find these parts of the film almost unwatchable, as I KNOW the songs should be played at higher pitch.
Hopefully, this provides some insight as to why many of the songs are at the wrong pitch."
- I wonder if anybody except audiophiles will notice it. I have an earlier DVD version of the movie and I never noticed it.
Last edited:
